Sunday, 17 January 2016

Forecasts, Monkeys (with keyboards) and UK Interest Rates: a case for no change

I was tickled by a comment by the RBS reported in last week's weekend newspapers - who evidently came top in the Wacky Races of would-be forecasters for 2015 for the British economy who used an apt (except perhaps to its number crunchers) riposte about "monkeys with keyboards".
With monkeys of my own in our household, I thought it only fair to get their take on the key forecasts for 2016!
Alas they were too interested in the latest I-Phone and Japanese Animes as target-forecasts than that of something called GDP or seismic developments in the FTSE 100. So we stuck to one indicator...UK interest rates.
With  that UK base rates at 0.25% for the last 7 years and most folk again writing about a definite rate rise this year, the "consensus monkey forecast" at chez nous was a dead-heat: up, down and one flat. I particularly enjoyed the outlier of the forecast for a reduction...(forecaster age 8 mind!). So the average or mean is no change.
Which is essentially my own personal view: ie no change in 2016 with a 70% probability and a 30% chance of a rate increase - and if so, yes by 25 basis points.
Sound UK Fundamentals but plenty of Geo Political and Economic Volatility
The consensus is that UK interest rates will go up later this year and by a quarter of a percent.
The Bank of England typically takes its cue from the trend in US interest rate setting and and the recent rise in the US Feds Funds rate by 0.25% would normally suggest a reaction this side of the "pond". Both the US and UK economies are now in a growth phase, as indeed is much of the EU. But there are lot of downside risks that suggest that the economic take-off in the UK may yet be more subdued than envisaged.
Things are extremely fluid and gittery geo-politically and are not only causing havoc in the financial markets in January but will also pose a sustained and growing risk that the consensus forecasts may not yet have fully factored in further potential volatility and resultant caution on the part of the Bank of England to hold off further monetary tightening, particularly if there will be further deflationary pressure.
Key factors
  1. the slow-down and convulsions of the Chinese economy could yet reveal some nasty black holes (quasi-fiscal liabilities) whilst driving a general softening in external demand that will hit SE Asia and in turn is lead to what looks like more than a cyclical depression in commodities - particularly that of the black gold. With China responsible for about a third of global growth in trade in recent years, cooling external demand and in Emerging Markets will together hit external demand for the EU, including the UK.
  2. A devaluation of the Chinese exchange rate is now likely and this in turn will continue to mean cheaper Chinese imports in the UK and elsewhere.
  3. A Chinese devaluation may set off further devaluations in SE Asia in particular as the Asian tigers seek tor retain competitive edge in the tradeable sector...maybe good for imported inflation into the EU and the UK but also likely to add to FX risks in these countries given the increasing prevalence of dollar borrowing (deja vu late 90s?).
  4. With investment houses now rushing to reverse previous gilded forecasts that we were living in a new normal of above USD 100 per barrel just a couple of years back, they are now rushing the other way to come up with ever lower sub-50, 40 or even 30 dollars per barrel. Whatever the macro reasons in terms of underlying demand and supply and alternatives (shale gas) and substitution effects (solar, hydro, wind et al) that explain the decline in the price of hydrocarbons, the fact is that this is clearly a positive external shock and deflationary for the UK. If it is sustained then the deflationary impact will be higher than anticipated - ie imported inflation will be lower.
  5. Within the UK the efforts taken by both the fiscal and monetary authorities to cool down the housing market will have a pronounced effect from April 6 when a further 3% transaction tax (Stamp Duty) kicks in for anyone buying an additional property and lending criteria are further tightened by the central bank.
So, as in 2015, I'm forecasting a baseline that UK base rates remain unchanged in 2016.

No comments:

Post a comment